Travelers are voting Motel In The Pines, Wyndhamvr Flagstaff and Residence Inn Marriott Flagsta as the best of 243 hotels in Coconino Reservoir. There are 142 hotels in Flagstaff a city just 45 km from Coconino Reservoir and 86 hotels in Cottonwood which is 142 km distant. The most popular of these are Best Western Pony Soldier Inn in Flagstaff and Comfortable home 2 miles from town in Cottonwood. You can find 1020 hotels in Arizona and 46189 hotels in the country of United States. Our members favorite in Arizona is Phantom Ranch and A place you feel like home is the top pick in United States. Want more? Check out our map of hotels in Coconino Reservoir.