Travelers are voting St. George Island as the best island near Apalachicola. There is 1 island near Fairhope a city just 180 km from Apalachicola. The most popular of these is Blakeley Island near Fairhope. You can find 15 islands near Florida and 150 islands in the country of United States. Our members favorite in Florida is St. George Island and Angel Island is the top pick in United States. Want more? Check out our map of islands near Apalachicola.