Travelers are voting Rushford Lake as the best lake in Allegany County. There are 4 lakes near Batavia a city just 37 km from Allegany County and 12 lakes near Canandaigua which is 45 km distant. The most popular of these are Canadice Lake near Batavia and Finger Lakes Region in Canandaigua. You can find 81 lakes in New York and 2109 lakes in the country of United States. Our members favorite in New York is Great Sacandaga Lake and Lake Superior is the top pick in United States. Want more? Check out our map of lakes in Allegany County.