Travelers are voting Bimini Big Game Club, Big Johns Hotel and Bimini Bay Resort And Marina as the best of 29 hotels in Cat Cay. There are 26 hotels in Freeport a city just 78 km from Cat Cay and 42 hotels in Nassau which is 126 km distant. The most popular of these are Royal Islander Hotel in Freeport and Atlantis Paradise Island in Nassau. You can find 125 Hotel in the country of Bahamas and Atlantis Paradise Island is our members favorite Hotel in all of Bahamas. Want more? Check out our map of hotels in Cat Cay.